| First Team | | | |
| 2022 | Drew Sanders | LB | AP |
| 2017 | Frank Ragnow | OL | CBS, PFF |
| 2016 | Frank Ragnow | OL | PFF |
| 2015 | Hunter Henry | TE | AFCA, AP, Athlon, ESPN.com, PS, SN, USA Today, WC |
| Sebastian Tretola | OG | SI |
| 2013 | Travis Swanson | C | USA Today |
| 2011 | Joe Adams | PR/AP | PFW, FWAA, SN |
| 2007 | Jonathan Luigs | C | CBS, CFN, FWAA, PS, Rivals, SN, WC |
| Felix Jones | KR/RB | PS, Rivals, Scout, WC |
| Darren McFadden | RB | AFCA, AP, CBS, CFN, FWAA, PFW, PS, Rivals, SN, WC |
| 2006 | Darren McFadden | RB | AFCA, AP, CBS, FWAA, PFW, SI, Scout, WC |
| 2005 | Felix Jones | KR/RB | CFN |
| 2003 | Shawn Andrews | OT | AFCA, AP, CFN, CNNSI, ESPN.com, FWAA, SN, WC |
| 2002 | Ken Hamlin | FS | CFN |
| Shawn Andrews | OT | AFCA, CFN, CNNSI, ESPN.com, FWAA, SN |
| 2001 | Jermaine Petty | LB | AAF, AFCA |
| 1998 | Brandon Burlsworth | OG | FN |
| 1989 | Jim Mabry | OT | AFCA, AP, WC |
| 1988 | Wayne Martin | DT | AP, FWAA, SN |
| Kendall Trainor | K | AFCA, AP, SN, WC |
| 1987 | Tony Cherico | DT | AFCA |
| 1986 | Greg Horne | P | AFCA |
| 1983 | Ron Faurot | DE | UPI |
| 1982 | Steve Korte | OG | AFCA, AP, FWAA, SN |
| Billy Ray Smith Jr. | DE | AFCA, AP, FWAA, SN, WC |
| 1981 | Bruce Lahay | K/P | FWAA |
| Billy Ray Smith Jr. | DE | AFCA, AP, FWAA, SN, WC |
| 1979 | Greg Kolenda | OT | AFCA, AP, FWAA, WC |
| 1978 | Dan Hampton | DT | AFCA |
| Jimmy Walker | DT | FWAA |
| 1977 | Leotis Harris | OG | AFCA, AP, WC |
| Steve Little | K/P | AFCA, FWAA, SN |
| 1976 | Steve Little | K/P | AFCA |
| 1971 | Bill McClard | K | FWAA, SN |
| 1970 | Bruce James | DE | FWAA |
| Dick Bumpas | DT | NEA, AP |
| Chuck Dicus | End | AFCA, AP, FN, WC |
| Bill McClard | K | AFCA |
| 1969 | Rodney Brand | C | AP, FWAA, WC |
| Cliff Powell | LB | AFCA |
| Chuck Dicus | End | AFCA |
| 1968 | Jim Barnes | OG | AP |
| 1966 | Martine Bercher | S | AFCA, UPI |
| Loyd Phillips | DT | AFCA, AP, FWAA, SN, WC |
| 1965 | Glen Ray Hines | OT | AFCA, AP, FWAA, WC |
| Bobby Crockett | End | FWAA |
| Loyd Phillips | DT | AFCA, AP, WC |
| 1964 | Ronnie Caveness | LB | AFCA, AP, FWAA, NEA, SN |
| 1963 | Ronnie Caveness | LB | FN |
| 1962 | Billy Moore | QB | FWAA |
| 1961 | Lance Alworth | Back | FWAA |
| 1960 | Wayne Harris | LB | FWAA |
| 1959 | Jim Mooty | Back | AP |
| 1954 | Bud Brooks | OG/DT | AFCA, AP, FWAA, WC |
| 1948 | Clyde Scott | TB | AFCA, AP |
| 1937 | Jim Benton | End | NANA |
| 1936 | Jack Robbins | QB | AABF |
| 1929 | Wear Schoonover | End | GR, NYS |
| | | |
| Second/Third/Fourth Team | | | |
| 2022 | Drew Sanders | LB | 2nd (AFCA, FWAA, SN, WC) |
| Beaux Limmer | OL | 3rd (PFF) |
| 2021 | Montaric Brown | DB | 3rd (PS) |
| Treylon Burks | WR | 2nd (PFF) |
| Bumper Pool | LB | 3rd (PS) |
| 2020 | Grant Morgan | LB | 2nd (WC, AFCA), 3rd (PS) |
| Jalen Catalon | DB | 3rd (PS) |
| 2017 | Frank Ragnow | OL | 2nd (FWAA, PS), 3rd (AP) |
| 2016 | Frank Ragnow | OL | 4th (PS) |
| Dan Skipper | OL | 2nd (AFCA) |
| 2015 | Alex Collins | RB | 3rd (Athlon), 4th (PS) |
| Hunter Henry | TE | 2nd (SI) |
| Sebastian Tretola | OL | 2nd (AP, Athlon, SN) |
| 2013 | Travis Swanson | C | 2nd (CSM), 4th (PS) |
| 2012 | Cobi Hamilton | WR | 3rd (AP, PS) |
| 2011 | Joe Adams | PR/AP | 2nd (AP, PS, SI, WC) |
| 2010 | D.J. Williams | TE | 2nd (Scout, SI), 3rd (AP) |
| 2007 | Felix Jones | KR/RB | 2nd (AP) |
| Jonathan Luigs | C | 2nd (AP) |
| Robert Felton | OG | 2nd (AP, PS, Rivals) |
| 2006 | Jonathan Luigs | C | 3rd (AP) |
| Stephen Parker | OG | 2nd (SN) |
| Tony Ugoh | OT | 2nd (Rivals), 3rd (AP) |
| 1999 | Kenoy Kennedy | FS | 3rd (AP) |
| Anthony Lucas | WR | 3rd (AP) |
| 1998 | Brandon Burlsworth | OG | 2nd (AP) |
| 1979 | Ish Ordonez | K | 2nd (UPI) |
| 1959 | Jim Mooty | Back | 3rd (NEA) |
| 1937 | Jim Benton | End | 2nd (ChP), 3rd (AP, CP) |
| 1929 | Wear Schoonover | End | 2nd (UPI), 3rd (AP, INS) |
| | | |
| Awards Organizations Legend | | | |
| AABF | All-America Board of Football | | |
| AAFF | All-American Football Foundation | | |
| AFCA | American Football Coaches Association | | |
| AP | Associated Press | | |
| CBS | CBSSports.com | | |
| CFN | College Football News | | |
| ChP | Charles Parker | | |
| CNNSI | CNN Sports Illustrated | | |
| CP | Central Press | | |
| FN | Football News | | |
| FWAA | Football Writers Association of America | | |
| GR | Grantland Rice | | |
| INS | International News Service | | |
| NANA | North American Newspaper Alliance | | |
| NEA | Newspaper Enterprise Association | | |
| NYS | New York Sun | | |
| PFF | Pro Football Focus | | |
| PFW | Pro Football Weekly | | |
| PS | Phil Steele College Football | | |
| SI | Sports Illustrated | | |
| SN | Sporting News | | |
| UPI | United Press International | | |
| WC | Walter Camp Foundation | | |
